Is there a good quote to close ratio for P&C agents?

Your quote to close ratio is the share of quoted prospects who end up buying a policy from you. It sounds simple. In practice, agencies count it in different ways and quote very different kinds of prospects, so a single number from someone else tells you more about how they count than about how well they sell.

Agents report a wide spread. In a 2011 thread on Insurance Forums, a captive carrier's product manager said his company's statewide close ratio in Nevada was about 31%. Other captive agents in the same thread reported under 20%, 1 or 2 out of 10, and in one case 8 out of 10. One agent said callers from referrals or direct mail closed about 1 in 7, while internet leads closed about 1 in 20.

Those are old stories from one forum, so treat them as color. They do show what swings the number most, which is how an agency defines a quote and where its prospects come from.

Lead vendors publish their own figures too. EverQuote's agent blog says agents see average bind rates of 20% to 30% on its consumer-initiated inbound calls. QuoteWizard's agent site lists 30% reported close rates on its live transfer leads. These are marketing claims, measured the vendor's way. InsureScales does not publish or promise a close rate, because it depends on your carriers, your producers, and your follow-up.

How to calculate your quote-to-close ratio

The math is easy. The hard part is counting the same way every month and for every source. Lock down three definitions first.

  1. 1

    Decide what counts as a quote

    A quick price indication and a full quote with drivers, vehicles, and prior insurance checked are very different. One agent in the forum thread pointed out that producers often run a rough price first and only enter a formal quote when it looks competitive, which pushes the ratio up. Pick one definition, such as a full quote presented to the prospect, and use it everywhere.
  2. 2

    Count households or policies, not both

    A household that buys auto and home is one sale by household and two by policy. Use households for close ratio and track policies separately for production. Mixing them flatters sources that send more bundles.
  3. 3

    Set a time window

    Count a quote as closed only if it binds within a set window after the quote, for example 30 days. Only calculate the ratio for quotes old enough to have finished that window, or your newest source will always look the worst.

Quote-to-close is one step in a longer chain. A source can look great here and still be expensive if your team only reaches a few of its leads, so track the steps around it too.

NumberHow to work it outWhat it tells you
Contact ratePeople reached ÷ leads or transfers receivedWhether you can get prospects on the phone
Quote rateHouseholds quoted ÷ people reachedWhether prospects fit your carriers and want a quote
Quote-to-close ratioHouseholds bound ÷ households quotedHow well your price, pitch, and follow-up win
Lead-to-closeHouseholds bound ÷ leads or transfers receivedWhat you get from each unit you paid for

Why the ratio changes by lead source

The same producer with the same carriers will close at different rates depending on where the prospect came from. How they found you, how many other agencies are calling them, and how long ago they asked for a quote all change the conversation.

SourceWhere the prospect is when you quoteWhat tends to pull the ratio down
ReferralSent by someone they trust, often with a reason to act nowHard to get in volume, so small numbers swing a lot
Shared web leadFilled out a quote form, and more than one agency may call. EverQuote, for example, says its shared leads go to up to three agents.Racing other agencies, and a shopper comparing on price
Aged leadAsked for a quote weeks or months agoMany have bought already or stopped shopping, so fewer reach a quote
Live transferOn the phone with your producer, having just said they want a quoteMissed calls, and prospects your carriers cannot price well

One agent in the forum thread argued that referrals from real estate contacts are far less price sensitive than internet shoppers. Someone closing on a house cares more about getting it done than about a small premium difference. That fits what many producers see, and it is why a blended close ratio across all sources hides more than it shows.

Close ratio also only tells you part of the story. A source with a lower ratio can still cost less per policy if each lead is cheap enough. Our guide to how much live transfer leads cost walks through cost per policy, and aged vs shared leads vs live transfers compares cost per conversation.

What moves your quote-to-close ratio

Speed to the first call

With web leads, the first agency to reach the shopper gets the first real conversation. A 2011 Harvard Business Review study of online sales leads found that most companies were not responding nearly fast enough. With shared leads, a slow first call often means you quote someone who already heard two other prices.

Answer rate on your side

With live transfers, the race moves to your phone. If a transfer rings through to voicemail, you lose the moment the prospect was ready to talk. At InsureScales, an unanswered transfer is billable when the prospect waits 20 seconds or more, so a missed call costs you a quote and money. Our article on what happens when a live transfer hits voicemail covers how to avoid paying for those. Set your calling hours and how many calls you take at once to match the people you actually have on the phones. You can see how that works for auto insurance live transfers.

Follow-up after the quote

Plenty of quotes do not close on the first call. The prospect wants to check with a spouse, wait until their renewal date, or see one more price. A written follow-up schedule, such as a call the next day and another before their renewal, gives more of those quotes a chance to close. Log each step so you can see which one produces the sale.

Carrier appetite and pricing

Your ratio can only be as good as your carriers' prices for the people you quote. Much of the 2011 forum thread was an argument about exactly this, with producers blaming rates and the home office blaming activity. Both matter. If your carriers are not competitive for young drivers or for homes in certain ZIP codes, filter those prospects out at the source instead of quoting them and losing. An independent agency with several carriers can often place more of what it quotes than a captive agent with one.

How to track close ratio by source so you can compare vendors

  1. 1

    Tag every prospect with a source

    Add a required source field in your CRM or agency management system, with one value per vendor and product, such as "Vendor A shared auto" and "Vendor A calls". Nothing gets entered without it.
  2. 2

    Log everything you paid for

    Count every lead or transfer you were charged for, including the ones you never reached. For InsureScales transfers, your portal lists each transfer with a recording, so you can match every call to a quote or a no-quote.
  3. 3

    Log quotes with your one definition

    Use the same quote definition and the same household rule for every source.
  4. 4

    Close the window

    When the follow-up window ends, mark each quote bound or lost. Then work out the ratio for that batch.
  5. 5

    Put the cost next to it

    Divide what you spent on the source by households bound. Cost per bound household is the number that tells you which vendor to keep.
Example only. Made-up numbers, not vendor prices, InsureScales prices, or real results.
SourceSpentQuotedBoundQuote-to-closeCost per bound household
Vendor A shared leads$1,000 (125 leads at $8)25520%$200
Vendor B transfers$1,500 (20 transfers at $75)14429%$375

In this example, Vendor B has the better close ratio and still costs more per household. The comparison is not finished, though. Vendor A's number leaves out the hours your team spent dialing 125 leads to find 25 people to quote. Add that time at what it costs you, and the gap may shrink or flip. Run the numbers for your own agency in our live transfer cost calculator.

Two cautions before you drop a vendor. First, give each source enough quotes. With 10 quotes, one sale moves the ratio by 10 points. Second, compare sources over the same months, because a carrier rate change moves every source at once.

What a good ratio looks like for your agency

The benchmark that matters is your own. Once you count quotes, households, and time windows the same way, you can see whether a source is getting better or worse, whether a new producer is closing like the rest of the team, and whether a rate change hurt you. That is more useful than any number from a forum or a vendor's sales page.

Set a baseline for each source over a few months. Then change one thing at a time, such as faster first calls, a tighter follow-up schedule, or filters that match your carriers, and watch what happens to the ratio and to cost per bound household.

Sources