Insurance telemarketer routing a live transfer call to an agency team
Blog

Insurance Telemarketing Services: What Agencies Should Expect

Most agencies get insurance telemarketing done one of three ways. You can hire your own caller, outsource to a calling team or appointment setter, or pay per live transfer. This guide to telemarketing for insurance agencies compares what each option costs in money and management time, who pays for the calls nobody answers, and what to ask before you sign.

June 12, 20269 min readBy the InsureScales teamUpdated Nov 7, 2026Insurance telemarketing services

What are the ways to get insurance telemarketing done?

Most agencies use one of three: hire their own caller, outsource to a calling team or appointment setter, or pay per live transfer. A telemarketer you hire typically costs $15 to $25 an hour, paid whether anyone is transferred or not. With pay per live transfer, the vendor pays for the dialing and the dead ends.

What are insurance telemarketing services?

Insurance telemarketing services are outbound calling programs that reach people, find the ones who want a quote, and get them talking to your agency. For insurance agents and brokers, the work has a clear line. The caller opens the conversation. Your licensed producers handle quotes, advice, applications, and binding.

Most agencies look at telemarketing for the same reason. Producers are busy quoting and servicing, so nobody has time to dial. The fix can be a person you hire, a company you outsource to, or a vendor you pay per live transfer. Each one charges for something different and leaves different work and risk with you.

Three ways to handle telemarketing for insurance agencies

Here is how the three options compare on the things that decide your real cost.

What you pay for
Hire a telemarketer
Hours worked
Outsource a calling team
Hours, appointments, or a monthly fee, depending on the contract
Pay per live transfer
Live transfers that meet the counting rule
Typical cost
Hire a telemarketer
Typically $15 to $25 an hour, plus hiring and training time
Outsource a calling team
Varies by company and contract. Get it in writing
Pay per live transfer
A set price per transfer. InsureScales gives it on a quote
Your management time
Hire a telemarketer
High. You recruit, train, script, monitor, and cover absences
Outsource a calling team
Medium. You manage the vendor, review calls, and chase appointments
Pay per live transfer
Lower. You set states, hours, daily cap, and calls at once, then answer
Who pays for no-answers
Hire a telemarketer
You. Every unanswered dial is paid time
Outsource a calling team
You, on hourly plans. On appointment plans, ask about no-shows
Pay per live transfer
The vendor pays for the dialing. Ask if a transfer your team misses still counts
Who runs DNC, calling hours, and scripts
Hire a telemarketer
You
Outsource a calling team
The vendor. Ask to see how
Pay per live transfer
The vendor. Ask to see how

None of the three guarantees a quote or a sale. What changes is who pays for the dialing that goes nowhere, and how much of your week goes into running it.

Hiring your own insurance telemarketer

A telemarketer on your payroll typically costs $15 to $25 an hour. You pay for every hour worked, whether the calls turn into transfers or not. The wage is only part of it. You also need calling data, a phone system or dialer, access to do-not-call lists, a script, and someone to listen to calls and coach.

Management time is the cost agencies tend to miss. Someone has to recruit, train, fill in for sick days, and start over when the caller quits. That someone is usually the owner or a producer who would rather be quoting.

Example math

With made-up numbers: a caller at $20 an hour working 30 hours a week costs $600 in wages. If they transfer 15 interested people that week, each transfer cost $40 in wages alone. If they transfer 5, each one cost $120. Payroll taxes, data, phone costs, and your own time come on top.

The no-answer risk is all yours. A slow day of voicemails and hang-ups costs the same as a good one. Hiring makes sense when you already run a calling floor, have a manager with time to coach, and want full control of the list and the script. Our guide to hiring a telemarketer vs. buying lead lists goes deeper on that choice.

Outsourcing to a calling team or appointment setter

An outsourced telemarketing company supplies the callers, so you skip the hiring. Contracts usually charge by the hour, per appointment set, or a monthly fee for a set amount of calling. Each one puts the risk in a different place.

Hourly or monthly calling

You pay for time on the phones. A week of voicemails and hang-ups costs the same as a good week, so the no-answer risk stays with you.

Per appointment set

The caller books a future call or meeting. The risk moves to the show rate. Ask whether you pay for no-shows and how fast your team has to confirm.

An appointment is a promise to talk later. Some people will not pick up when your producer calls at the booked time, so your team has to follow up fast and more than once.

Management time drops, but it does not go away. You still approve the script, review recordings, and chase appointments. Your agency's name is on those calls too, so check how the vendor handles do-not-call lists, calling hours, and consent. Outsourcing fits when your producers work from a calendar and you want someone else to hire the callers.

Paying per live transfer

With pay per transfer, a vendor's callers dial, check for interest and basic fit, and transfer the interested person live to your producer. You pay a set price for each transfer that counts.

The vendor pays for the dialing, the no-answers, and the screening. You carry the risk that a transfer does not turn into a policy. Your management time is mostly setup: which states, which hours, how many transfers a day, and how many calls your team can take at once. After that, your job is to answer the phone and quote.

Read the counting rule closely, because it decides what you pay. Here are the InsureScales rules. Answered calls are timed from the first ring at your agency. Ringing counts. Our screening before the transfer does not.

Your team answers

  • Under 75 seconds. Not billable.
  • 75 seconds to under 5 minutes. Billable, unless our quality team approves a valid return.
  • 5 minutes or longer. Billable. No ordinary lead-quality returns.

Nobody answers

  • Prospect hangs up in under 20 seconds. Not billable.
  • Prospect waits 20 seconds or more, then hangs up. Billable while delivery is active and not paused. You get their details so you can call back.

That second rule matters. A missed transfer can still count, so keep a producer free during your calling hours or lower how many calls you take at once.

InsureScales works this way for auto, home, and renters insurance only. Each transfer goes to one agency. You prepay, unused transfers carry forward, and every transfer has a recording in your portal. Calling data is included, and your own lists can be added. See what comes with our live transfer service or how it works for auto insurance live transfers.

To see how this model stacks up against other ways of buying calls, read pay per transfer vs. pay per call vs. pay per lead. For what drives the price, see how much live transfers cost. Pay per transfer fits when your producers are busy and you want conversations without running a calling floor.

Get your price per transfer

Tell us the lines you want, your states, your calling hours, and your daily volume. We will give you your price per transfer.

Compliance: who runs DNC, calling windows, and consent

Telemarketing insurance to consumers comes with federal and state calling rules. Treat them as daily controls that someone owns. Whoever makes the calls should be able to show you each of these:

  • Do-not-call scrubbing. Check numbers against the National Do Not Call Registry and your own internal do-not-call list before dialing, and honor every request to stop calling.
  • Calling windows. Call only during permitted hours in the prospect's local time. State rules can differ from federal rules.
  • Consent. Know what consent your calls need, which depends on how you dial and who you call, and keep records you can pull up.
  • Scripts and disclosures. Use an approved script that says who is calling and why, with no misleading openers.
  • The licensing line. Keep callers out of quotes, advice, and policy details. Your licensed producers take over for that.

If you hire your own caller, every one of these is your job. If you outsource or pay per transfer, the vendor runs them day to day. The calls still reach your agency, so ask how each control works. At InsureScales, every campaign runs with these controls:

DNC scrubbing

Calling data is scrubbed against do-not-call lists before we dial.

Calling-window rules

We only call during allowed hours for the prospect.

Approved scripts

Every call follows an approved script with the required disclosures.

No quoting, binding, or advice

Our callers never quote, bind, or give advice. Your licensed producers handle the insurance conversation.

These are operating controls, not a legal guarantee.

This is general information, not legal advice. Rules vary by state and by how you dial. Check your setup with a lawyer who knows telemarketing rules.

What to ask insurance telemarketing companies

Whichever model you pick, these questions show you what you are buying. Get the answers in writing.

  • What exactly am I paying for: an hour, an appointment, a lead, or a live transfer?
  • Who pays for the calls nobody answers, and for appointments that do not show?
  • When does the clock start on a transfer, and how long does a call have to run to count?
  • What happens when my team misses a transfer?
  • Does each prospect go to my agency only, or to other agencies too?
  • What can I send back, how fast, and who reviews it?
  • Can I hear a recording of every call I pay for?
  • Who scrubs do-not-call lists, how are calling hours enforced, and can I see the script?
  • Do your callers ever quote, give advice, or discuss coverage? The answer should be no.
  • What happens to money I prepaid if I pause or stop?

Captive agents should also check their carrier's rules on outside vendors before signing with any telemarketing company.

Insurance telemarketing FAQ

Are telemarketing insurance leads worth buying?

It depends on what you get. A list of numbers to dial is cheap but needs your team to call it. A live transfer from a telemarketing team arrives as a conversation with someone who wants a quote. Compare both by cost per policy, not per lead.

How much do insurance telemarketing services cost?

It depends on what you pay for. A telemarketer you hire typically costs $15 to $25 an hour, plus the time to hire, train, and manage. Outsourced calling teams usually charge by the hour, per appointment, or by the month. Pay-per-transfer vendors charge a set price per live transfer, and InsureScales gives that price on a quote.

Is appointment setting or a live transfer better for insurance agents?

It depends on how your producers work. With appointment setting, the prospect agrees to talk later, so you carry the risk that they do not show or pick up. A live transfer puts the prospect on the phone with your producer right away, so someone has to be free to answer during your calling hours.

Who pays for the calls nobody answers?

With your own telemarketer or an hourly calling team, you do, because you pay for time. With pay per transfer, the vendor pays for the dialing. At InsureScales, a transfer your team misses can still count if the prospect waits 20 seconds or more while delivery is active and not paused.

Can an insurance telemarketer quote a policy?

Our callers never quote, bind, or give advice. They find people who want a quote and transfer them to your licensed producers. If you hire your own caller, check your state licensing rules before they talk about coverage or price.

What should I ask insurance telemarketing companies before signing?

Ask what you pay for, who pays for no-answers, when a transfer counts, whether prospects go to other agencies, what you can send back, and whether you can hear every call. Ask who runs do-not-call scrubbing and calling hours. Captive agents should also check their carrier's rules on outside vendors.

Do I need my own calling list?

Not with InsureScales. Calling data is included, and your agency's own lists, such as past customers or x-dates, can be added.

Sources

Related reading