How much do auto insurance leads cost? Reported prices by type

There is no single price list for auto insurance leads. Vendors publish their own numbers, and they don't agree. The table below shows what each source reports for auto, with the date we checked. Read every number as one vendor's claim about its own market, not as a quote for your agency.

Reported auto insurance lead prices, checked September 2026
Lead typeReported priceWho reports it
Aged leads$0.15 to $1.00 per lead, by ageAged Lead Store (published March 13, 2026)
Aged leads$0.25 to $2.00 per lead, by ageInsureLeads (updated March 4, 2026)
Shared web leadsAbout $3 to $10 per leadInsureScales, the figure our site uses
Shared web leads$15 to $30 per lead, fresh and sharedAged Lead Store
Real-time web leads$1.50 to $30 per leadThe Leads Warehouse (July 28, 2026)
Exclusive web leads$25 to $60 per leadAged Lead Store
Exclusive web leads$35 per leadInsureLeads
Inbound calls$45 per callThe Leads Warehouse
Inbound calls$24 to $40 per call, for calls it generatesQuotely (August 2026)
Live transfers$90 per connected callInsureLeads
Live transfersPrice on a quoteInsureScales

Home leads are listed higher at the one vendor above that breaks them out. InsureLeads lists aged home leads at $0.30 to $2.50, exclusive home web leads at $45, and home live transfers at $100 per connected call.

The shared-lead gap is the widest. Our own pages use about $3 to $10 for a shared lead, while Aged Lead Store lists fresh shared auto leads at $15 to $30. Each vendor also defines "shared" and "per call" its own way, which is part of why the numbers spread.

What each lead type includes

The price only makes sense once you know what you are buying. Here is what each type gives you, and who does the dialing.

Aged leads

An aged lead is an older quote request, often weeks or months old, sold at a discount after the first buyers have already called it. It is the cheapest record you can buy. Your team does all the dialing, and the person may have bought a policy already or may not remember asking.

Shared web leads

A shared lead is a recent quote request sent to more than one agency. You race the other buyers to the phone, and you pay for the lead whether or not you reach the person.

Exclusive web leads

An exclusive web lead is a recent quote request sold to one agency. You still have to reach the person, but you are the only agency calling from that sale.

Inbound calls (pay per call)

With pay per call, a shopper dials a number from an ad or a quote site and is routed to your phone. You pay for each call that meets the vendor's rule. Ask what the rule is, such as a minimum call length, and when the timer starts.

Live transfers

With live transfers, a screener confirms the person wants a quote and connects them to your producer while they are still on the line. The screener may take inbound calls or call people from a list. You pay per transfer that meets the counting rule. At InsureScales, answered transfers under 75 seconds are free, and an unanswered transfer is free if the prospect hangs up in under 20 seconds. Each transfer goes to one agency.

For a side-by-side of the first two against transfers, see aged vs shared leads vs live transfers. For the billing models, see pay per transfer vs pay per call vs pay per lead.

Why the published prices disagree

Here are four reasons the numbers spread so far.

  • Definitions. "Shared" can mean one other agency or several. QuoteWizard's agent page, for example, says it sells each lead to at most four agents. Vendors also set different minimum lengths before a call is billed.
  • Lead tiers and states. Vendors price by who the person is and where they live. EverQuote's agent FAQ splits its products into lead types such as Premium, Preferred, Standard, and Non-Standard.
  • Bidding. Some marketplaces price by auction. SmartFinancial's agent FAQ says it recommends a bid and that agents in competitive areas may want to raise it.
  • Who is writing. Every price page we found comes from a company that sells at least one of these types. That includes Aged Lead Store, InsureLeads, The Leads Warehouse, Quotely, and us.

Cost per policy: names vs conversations

A web lead or an aged lead is a name. Your team still has to reach the person, and many never answer. A live transfer or an inbound call is already a conversation when it reaches you. So the math needs a reach step for leads, and the time your producers spend dialing.

Here is an example with made-up numbers. They are not market data, not InsureScales prices, and not picked to make any type win. Every type uses the same close rate of 1 policy per 10 conversations, 5 minutes of dialing per web or aged lead, and producer time at $20 an hour.

Example only. Made-up prices, reach rates, close rate, and dialing times.
TypeExample price and reachLead spend per policyExample dialing time per policyTotal per policy
Aged leads$0.50 each, you reach 1 in 20200 leads = $10016.7 hours = $333$433
Shared web leads$8 each, you reach 1 in 550 leads = $4004.2 hours = $83$483
Exclusive web leads$35 each, you reach 2 in 525 leads = $8752.1 hours = $42$917
Inbound calls$45 per billed call, all answered10 calls = $450None$450
Live transfers$90 per transfer, your team answers 85%11.8 transfers = $1,059None$1,059

Don't read a winner into this table. The results swing on contact rate and close rate, and small changes reorder the list:

  • Contact rate. If you reach 1 in 40 aged leads instead of 1 in 20, aged leads go from $433 to $867 per policy.
  • Close rate. If your team closes 1 in 20 conversations instead of 1 in 10, every total doubles.
  • Answer rate. If your team answers 95% of transfers instead of 85%, transfers go from $1,059 to $947 per policy.
  • Your time. At $40 an hour instead of $20, the dialing column doubles, and aged leads go from $433 to $767 per policy.

Plug in your own numbers for each source you buy. Track how many leads you reach, how long that takes, and how many conversations become policies. For the live transfer side, our live transfer cost-per-policy calculator does the math, and our guide to what live transfer leads cost covers what drives a transfer price.

The example counts every transfer as billed, answered or not. That is the worst case, and real rules vary by vendor. At InsureScales, an unanswered transfer is billable if the prospect waits 20 seconds or more while delivery is active and not paused. This includes calls that ring through to your agency voicemail. The wait is timed from the first ring. Pausing when nobody can pick up keeps those calls off your bill.

Where hiring your own caller fits

Some agencies skip vendors and hire a caller. A hired telemarketer typically costs $15 to $25 an hour. You also pay for calling data, a dialer, training, and someone to manage the work. With made-up numbers: at $20 an hour and one live conversation handed to a producer every two hours, each conversation costs $40 in wages before any of those extras. If you already run a calling floor, that can work well. Our comparison of hiring a telemarketer vs buying lead lists goes deeper.

How to compare the prices you are quoted

  • Get the unit price and the rule for what counts, such as seconds for calls or number of agencies for leads.
  • Ask how many other agencies get the same person, now or later.
  • Ask for the return reasons and the deadline in writing.
  • Track conversations, quotes, and policies by source for at least 30 days.
  • Compare cost per policy, not cost per lead.

If you are weighing transfers, our auto insurance live transfers page explains how ours work for car owners. Quotes and sales are not guaranteed with any lead type, including ours.

Sources