Why renters insurance leads often start with a car
A renters policy on its own is a small sale. What makes renters insurance leads worth a call is usually the car. In 2024, about 46.1 million US households rented their home, and about 82% of them had at least one vehicle available, according to the Census Bureau's American Community Survey. So most renters prospects also need auto insurance.
The premium gap is real. NAIC figures published by the Insurance Information Institute put the average renters premium at $171 a year in 2022. Average auto insurance spending was $1,282 per insured vehicle in 2023. Those are different years and different measures, but the point holds. On average, the car carries the much bigger bill.
| Figure | Number | Source and year |
|---|---|---|
| Renter-occupied households | About 46.1 million | Census ACS, 2024 |
| Share with at least one vehicle | About 82% | Census ACS, 2024 |
| Average renters premium | $171 a year | NAIC via Triple-I, 2022 |
| Average auto spending per insured vehicle | $1,282 a year | NAIC via Triple-I, 2023 |
That is why it makes sense to treat a renters conversation as an auto conversation first. The renters policy rides along. It gives the household a second policy with your agency and a reason to stay when the auto renewal comes around.
What a renters live transfer is
A live transfer is a prospect handed to your agency on a live call. A renters live transfer from InsureScales is a renter with a car who wants a quote. Our caller confirms they want a quote and transfers them to your producer while they are still on the phone. Each transfer goes to one agency, so no other agency is on that call.
Our callers do not quote, explain coverage, or give advice. Your licensed producer does all of that. A renters form lead is different. It is a name and number you call later, and depending on the vendor, other agencies may buy the same person. You can see who we transfer and how on our renters insurance live transfers page.
How to quote renters and auto on one call
The order matters. Price the car first, because that is often what the renter wants to hear about. Then add renters while they are still listening.
- 1
Start with the car
Confirm they want a quote, then gather vehicles, drivers, current carrier, and renewal date. Our auto live transfer script has a sample opening you can copy.
- 2
Run the auto quote
Tell the renter what you are doing while the rater works. "I'm pulling your auto price now. It'll take about a minute."
- 3
Bridge to renters
"While that runs, do you have renters insurance where you live now?" If yes, ask who it is with and when it renews. If no, ask whether their lease requires it.
- 4
Ask the renters questions
The address and type of building, a rough value of their things (furniture, laptop, bike, clothes), who lives there, and the deductible they want. Ask how your carriers handle roommates and pets before you need to know.
- 5
Show both prices together
Many carriers give a discount when auto and renters are written together. Know how yours handle it, so your producer can show the combined price in one sentence.
- 6
Save the lease end date
Ask when their lease ends and whether they plan to buy. Note it as a future x-date, the date to call back about a home quote.
Your producer does not need a hard pitch for the renters policy. Asking the renter to add up what they would have to replace after a fire or theft is a simple way to start. Many renters are buying insurance on their own for the first time, so explain terms like deductible and liability limit in plain words.
When the renter pushes back
- "I only wanted a car quote." "That's fine. I'll finish your auto price first. Renters takes a few more questions, so I'll ask before we hang up if you'd like it priced too."
- "I don't own much." "Let's add it up quickly. Furniture, clothes, a laptop, a phone. Then you can decide if it's worth covering."
- "Can I add it later?" "Sure. I can price it now so you know the number, and we can start it whenever you're ready."
If the answer is still no, finish the auto sale and note it. A renter who says no today may say yes at the next auto renewal.
Get your agency ready for renters calls
A renters transfer only turns into two policies if the producer who picks up can quote both lines on the same call. Check these before the first transfer arrives.
- Both raters open. The producer should be able to price auto and renters without putting the renter on hold to find a second system.
- Your carriers' renters rules. Know the building types, roommate rules, pet questions, and minimums your carriers use, and how their multi-policy discount works.
- The right producers on the phones. Route renters calls to people licensed and comfortable quoting both lines.
- Hours and capacity that match. Set your calling hours and how many calls you take at once around the producers who can quote both.
How renters transfers are billed
Renters transfers follow the same clock as every other transfer. Answered calls are timed from the first ring at your agency. Ringing counts, and our screening before the transfer does not. An answered call under 75 seconds is not billable.
If nobody at your agency answers, this is how it works:
| What happens | Billable? |
|---|---|
| Prospect hangs up in under 20 seconds | Not billable. |
| Prospect waits 20 seconds or more, then hangs up | Billable while delivery is active and not paused. You get their details so you can call back. |
That includes calls that ring through to your agency voicemail.
There is no renters return rule
Our return reasons are set lists for auto and home only, and none of them covers the renters policy. A renter who decides against renters coverage is not a reason to send the call back. Two more limits apply to every transfer.
- Not quoting the prospect is not, by itself, a reason to return a call.
- We deliver interested, qualified prospects. Quotes and sales are not guaranteed.
The full return rules for auto and home, including deadlines, are in our guide to live transfer returns.
Keep the renter for the long run
A renter who buys auto and renters from you is the start of a client relationship. Keep in touch at each auto renewal so you hear about a move or a new car before another agency does.
The lease end date you saved is worth a call. When a renter becomes a homeowner, you already write their car, so you are in place to quote the home too. Our guide to x-date calling covers how agencies time those calls, and our page on home and auto live transfers shows how bundle calls are billed.
Track two numbers in your portal and your agency management system. How many renters transfers became auto policies, and how many of those also added renters. Those two numbers tell you whether the cross-sell is happening on your calls.
Sources
- U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2024 1-year, Table B25044 (Tenure by Vehicles Available) (checked Sept 2026)
- Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I), Facts + Statistics: Renters insurance (checked Sept 2026)
- Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I), Facts + Statistics: Auto insurance (checked Sept 2026)
