How to use this live transfer vendor checklist
Sales calls with lead vendors blur together. Every vendor says its prospects are interested and its rules are fair. This live transfer vendor checklist puts two vendors side by side on the same 12 questions, so you can see the differences in writing.
Copy the table below into a sheet or print it. Ask each vendor every question, and fill in the blank columns from their service agreement, FAQ, or an email. A promise on a call is worth less than the same promise in the agreement. If you want the reasoning behind each question, our guide on how to vet a live transfer vendor before you prepay goes through them one by one.
The live transfer vendor scorecard
The "Good answer" column describes a clear, checkable answer. It is not a price and not a pass mark. Leave a cell empty until you have the answer in writing.
| Criterion | What to ask | Good answer | Vendor A | Vendor B |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Billable seconds | How long must an answered call last before it counts? | A set number of seconds, written in the agreement. | ||
| When the clock starts | Is the call timed from the first ring, from pickup, or from when your screener dialed? | One clear start point. The vendor's own screening time is not counted. | ||
| Voicemail and unanswered calls | Do you bill if nobody answers or the call rings to voicemail? | A written rule with a short free window, and no billing while you are paused. | ||
| Return window and reasons | What can I return, by when, and who decides? | Written reasons by line, a set deadline, and a named review process. | ||
| What "exclusive" means | How many agencies get this caller, now or later? | One agency per transfer. The caller is not resold as a lead afterward. | ||
| Consent and call source | How are prospects found, and what did they agree to before the call? | A plain answer on inbound or outbound, the data source, and the script you can read. | ||
| Recording access | Can I hear every call I am billed for? | Every transfer recorded, and each charge tied to a specific call. | ||
| DNC scrubbing and calling windows | How do you scrub do-not-call lists, and what hours do you call? | Scrubbed against the national and internal DNC lists, calls only in allowed local hours. | ||
| Caps and concurrency | Can I set a daily cap and how many calls come in at once? | You set both and can change them without a sales call. | ||
| Pauses | Can I pause, and am I billed while paused? | Pause any time. Nothing billed while paused. | ||
| Unused balance | What happens to prepaid money I have not used? | It carries forward and is kept if you pause or close. | ||
| Contract minimums | Is there a minimum spend, minimum term, or automatic refill? | Terms stated in writing before you pay, with a clear way to stop. |
A simple way to score it
Give each row 2 points if the answer is clear and in writing, 1 point if it is verbal or vague, and 0 if the vendor won't answer. The top score is 24. The score measures how well you understand the offer. It says nothing about call quality, so a test still matters.
What each row protects you from
The billing rows
Billable seconds, the clock start, and the voicemail rule decide how many calls you pay for. Two vendors with the same price can bill very different numbers of calls. Our billable live transfer checklist explains each rule in more depth.
The fit rows
Returns, exclusivity, and the call source decide whether the calls you pay for are the calls you wanted. Ask for return reasons by line. For exclusivity, ask what happens to a caller your producer declines. For the call source, ask to read the script and hear two or three sample recordings before you sign.
The proof row
Recording access is how you check every other row. If you can't hear the call, you can't tell whether it met the billing rule, fit your filters, or deserves a return.
The compliance row
Ask how often the vendor scrubs its calling data and what hours it calls. The FTC's guide to the Telemarketing Sales Rule says sellers and telemarketers must remove numbers on the National Do Not Call Registry from their call lists at least every 31 days. Federal rules also bar telephone solicitations to homes before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. at the called person's location. Ask how the vendor handles state rules as well.
The control and money rows
Caps, pauses, unused balance, and minimums decide how much you can lose while you learn. A low daily cap and a same-day pause keep a bad week small. Money that carries forward means a pause doesn't cost you what you already paid.
How InsureScales answers each row
We sell live transfers, so here is how we would fill in our own column. Score us the same way you score everyone else.
| Criterion | InsureScales answer |
|---|---|
| Billable seconds | Under 75 seconds: not billable. 75 seconds to under 5 minutes: billable, unless our quality team approves a valid return. 5 minutes or longer: billable. No ordinary lead-quality returns. |
| When the clock starts | Answered calls are timed from the first ring at your agency. Ringing counts. Our screening before the transfer does not. |
| Voicemail and unanswered calls | Prospect hangs up in under 20 seconds: not billable. Prospect waits 20 seconds or more, then hangs up: billable while delivery is active and not paused. You get their details so you can call back. This includes calls that ring through to your agency voicemail. The wait is timed from the first ring. |
| Return window and reasons | Set reasons for auto and home. There is no renters return rule. Returns are accepted through the end of that billing week. Our quality team reviews every return. Only approved returns come off your bill. Not quoting the prospect is not, by itself, a reason to return a call. |
| What "exclusive" means | Each transfer goes to one agency. |
| Consent and call source | Our callers find people who want an auto, home, or renters quote and transfer them live. Calling data is included. Your agency's own lists can be added. Every call follows an approved script with the required disclosures. |
| Recording access | Listen to any transfer. Nothing is hidden. Each charge on your balance points to the specific call it paid for. |
| DNC scrubbing and calling windows | Calling data is scrubbed against do-not-call lists before we dial. We only call during allowed hours for the prospect. |
| Caps and concurrency | Set the most transfers you want in a day. Choose how many live calls your team can take at the same time. |
| Pauses | Nothing is billed while you are paused at your request, including missed transfers. |
| Unused balance | Prepaid transfers you have not received stay on your balance for later. If you pause or close your account, your unused balance is kept. You are never charged for capacity we did not deliver. If your prepaid balance runs low, delivery pauses on its own until you add more. |
| Contract minimums | You prepay per transfer at a price we give on a quote. Your service agreement sets the terms, so read it before you pay. |
The full rules are on our pricing and billing rules page. This is a plain-English summary. Your service agreement controls if anything here differs.
After you fill it in
- Cross out any vendor that left the billing rows blank.
- Ask the others to confirm their answers in the agreement itself.
- Run a small test with a low daily cap and listen to every billed call.
- After two to four weeks, compare cost per policy with our live transfer cost calculator.
A higher score means fewer surprises. It does not promise quotes or sales from any vendor, including us. Your own numbers after a test are the real tiebreaker.
Sources
- FTC, Complying with the Telemarketing Sales Rule (checked Sept 27, 2026)
- 16 CFR 310.4(c), calling time restrictions (eCFR) (checked Sept 27, 2026)
- 47 CFR 64.1200(c), telephone solicitation hours and the national do-not-call registry (eCFR) (checked Sept 27, 2026)
